Reading For Reviews

I’m at the point in my blogging life where I want to review every book that I read. This ultimately means that if I’m reading a book, I’m reading it with the intention of reviewing it at the end. There have actually been two books that I stopped reading halfway through because I couldn’t find anything positive that I wanted to discuss in the review. At this point in my reading journey, reading and reviewing are intimately linked.

But most recently I had a disquieting moment while reading a book. I noticed a particularly awkward sentence and thought to myself, “I should keep an eye out for more of these to mention it in the review.” That thought alone made me stop reading. Not only had I noticed the bad sentence but I had made a note to actively pursue the awkward sentences throughout the book, a decision that could greatly impact my final opinion on the work. After observing such a thought go through my head I had to take a step back and reflect: Does reading books with the intention of reviewing them genuinely alter the way that I read the book?

Noticing the Negatives

I think it’s inevitable that readers will notice awkward moments in books, whether it’s weird wording, grammatical errors or even spacing issues. We’ve all noticed that section of dialogue that fails to have quotations around the spoken words. And yes, I notice the “jokes” that aren’t funny, the “flirting” that’s just super awkward, and the “genius breakthrough” moments that are so obvious I want to beat the character over the head. But when I’m just reading for pleasure, I think it’s easier to pass these moments over and give the author a break.

It is true that when I want to review a book, I will gather all these bad moments in my head to try and gauge if they have negatively impacted my reading experience. If there were badly worded sentences, were there a lot of them? Were all the jokes so horribly unfunny that the story falls flat? If reviewing a book means balancing it on a scale to see if it was more good than bad, then yes, part of my job as a reviewer is to take note of all the unfavorable moments in the book.

Pulling out the Positives

But while I do take note of the bad parts of the books, I most definitely pay attention to the really good parts. I will constantly look for parts that are powerfully worded, that tug at my emotions or make my heart swell. These can be beautifully crafted and cleverly written, and usually I’m reveling in the language the author uses. These are the parts of the story that I flag to come back to later, and are often used as quotations in my reviews.

If I’m adding up the bad bits, of course I’m putting the good bits on the scale too. How many times did I laugh out loud? How many times did the book make me stop and think? How many times did I re-read a sentence because I enjoyed it so much? All of these moments together will make me enjoy a book more and will out weigh the bad stuff. Even if I’m noticing the negatives moments while reading, I am at the same time purposefully pursuing the great moments too.


All in all, I’m just trying to absorb everything about the book. I’m trying to take it all in; the setting, the world building, the characters, the plot – it goes on and on. So I try to dig my hands in deep and see what I can come up with.  When reading to review, I’m actively reading – I’m trying to think critically about the work I’m reading and assess not only my enjoyment of it, but how creative and innovative the story is. So while reading to review a book does influence the way that I’m reading, it’s simply making me more attentive and reflective about the work.


4 comments on “Reading For Reviews

  1. Reblogged this on Anthony Reese and commented:
    I have had this exact experience. As a student of creative writing, I am constantly analyzing every word, every sentence, and every paragraph that I read. I wonder what it’s like to be able to read like a normal person… I sure haven’t had that pleasure in quite some time.

    • It is very interesting how the reading experience changes over time. Now I can’t read a book without a pad of post-it notes beside me! Thanks for the reblog. :)

  2. John Guillen says:

    How come you have to review EVERY book you read? Couldn’t you just pick out a book every now and then that you won’t be reviewing afterward?

    • Of course I COULD… It’s mostly an issue of time management. I have so much going on that if I was reading books without reviewing them I would never have reviews posted on the blog. I’ve made the choice to review each book that I read so that I can optimize my time. :)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s